SPINDLE SELECTION

12 min read

HQD GDL vs GDF vs GDZ vs GDK: CNC Spindle Series Compared

Tool-change method and cooling narrow the spindle families; the exact tooling, operating point and mounting arrangement determine which configuration fits the machine. Compare GDL, GDF, GDZ and GDK against the same job and installation requirements, retaining the drawing and operating conditions for every candidate.

Key Requirements and Configuration Checks

  • Choose the required tooling and tool-change arrangement first.
  • Compare mounting structure within a series, not only between families.
  • Keep rated output, speed ranges and duty-qualified power distinct.

Match the proposed configuration to its applicable drawing, operating data and machine requirements. Resolve mounting dimensions, auxiliary services and operating limits before accepting a spindle for the intended installation.

DecisionUseful evidence
GDLAutomatic tool change; exact holder and release installation
GDFManual air-cooled tooling; physical mounting variant
GDZ / GDKManual water-cooled tooling; exact point, size and operating curve

Start with the machine's tooling and services

Among the configurations compared here, GDL provides automatic tool change, GDF uses manual tooling with air cooling, and GDZ and GDK use manual tooling with water cooling. GDL examples include both cooling arrangements. Use these differences to identify the required machine services, then compare the exact holder or collet interface, operating point and mounting drawing before specifying a spindle.

Next identify the required tool connection. GDL models use holder tapers, while the manual examples use ER tooling. A holder may itself contain an ER collet, so these labels describe different connections. Review the ER guide for cutter shanks and the ATC interface guide for spindle-to-holder selection.

Start with the machine's tooling and services
Machine requirementFirst series to reviewNext question
Automatic exchange using holdersGDLExact taper, retention, rack and release functions
Manual ER tooling with air coolingGDFMounting structure, tool interface and drive
Manual ER tooling with water coolingGDZ or GDKRequired working point, body, tooling and documented output
Keep an existing installationThe exact current configuration firstWhich bracket, drive, holders and services must remain?

If the machine requirements are still open, first record the job, tool inventory, required operating point and available mounting and services. Select the tool-change and cooling arrangement from those requirements, then compare the individual configurations. A series name identifies a useful starting family; machining capacity depends on the documented spindle conditions and the complete machine installation.

Compare 12 documented configurations

Compare each configuration using its documented output, speed, tooling and mounting references. Keep rated speed separate from a speed range or maximum value, and retain duty and ambient conditions with any power figure specified under those conditions. For GDL70, the S6-60% and TA20°C conditions must remain attached to the stated output when assessing the machine's operating requirement.

Compare 12 documented configurations
ConfigurationOutput descriptionSpeed descriptionInterface / coolingInstallation distinction
GDL40.5-ISO20-24Z/2.22.2 kW rated18,000 rated; 24,000 max rpmISO20 ATC / airSide auxiliaries; 372.5 mm overall
GDL70 ISO30 long nose9 kW at S6-60%, TA20°C24,000 rpmISO30 ATC / airLong nose; 551 mm overall
GDL120-30-24Z/5.55.5 kW rated24,000 rpm ratedBT30 ATC / water120 mm body; 136 mm clamp
GDF46-18Z/2.2 base mount2.2 kW rated18,000 rpm ratedER20 manual / airBase fixing structure
GDF46-18Z/2.2 housing mount2.2 kW rated18,000 rpm ratedER20 manual / airHousing fixing structure
GDF80-24Z/2.2B2.2 kW rated24,000 rpm ratedER20 manual / air80 mm body; 125 mm clamp
GDZ-18-20.8 kW rated24,000 rpm ratedER11B manual / water65 mm body; 224 mm overall
GDZ-17B1.5 kW rated24,000 rpm ratedER16 manual / water80 mm body; 241 mm overall
GDZ-232.2 kW rated24,000 rpm ratedER20 manual / water80 mm body; 120 mm clamp
GDK100-12-24Z/2.2-4.42.2 kW rated; separate curve conditions12,000–24,000 rpmER20 manual / water100 mm body; 140 mm clamp
GDK110-9-18Z/2.2-4.42.2 kW rated; separate curve conditions9,000–18,000 rpmER25 manual / water110 mm body; 155 mm clamp
GDK125-12-24Z/7.57.5 kW rated12,000–24,000 rpmER32 manual / water125 mm body; 190 mm clamp

A candidate must be compared using its own drawing and operating information, even when another configuration shares the same series, rated output or tool interface. Check the permitted support region, complete assembly dimensions, mass, winding and required services for every proposed alternative. Keep unresolved fields visible in the comparison record and obtain the supplied-unit information before accepting the configuration for installation.

GDL: compare the complete automatic-tool-change installation

GDL enters the shortlist when the machine needs compatible automatic tool exchange. The catalog includes ISO20, ISO25, ISO30, BT30 and BT40 interfaces, with different power, speed, cooling and assemblies. Choosing GDL therefore resolves the broad tool-change category but leaves the actual tooling and machine system to be selected.

GDL40.5 and GDL120 illustrate different requirements. GDL40.5 uses ISO20, air cooling and a rated point of 18,000 rpm at 300 Hz, with a separate maximum of 24,000 rpm at 400 Hz. GDL120 uses BT30, water cooling and a rated point of 24,000 rpm at 800 Hz. Its 25 kg assembly and 120 mm body also change the mechanical support question.

GDL70's long-nose ISO30 example is 551 mm overall and carries 9 kW at S6-60%, TA20°C. That figure should remain conditioned in a comparison. The nose geometry must be evaluated using mounting references and the holder assembly; overall length alone is not a tool-tip offset. Read the ATC requirements guide for release, sensing, rack movement and integration checks.

GDF: identify the mounting structure before ordering

GDF is the manual air-cooled family in the current catalog. It includes different physical structures and ER tooling choices. Air cooling describes the motor's cooling arrangement, not its fixing method, spindle position or complete electrical services. Start with the mounting drawing and the actual tool inventory when reviewing this family.

The base and housing versions of GDF46-18Z/2.2 both show 2.2 kW rated, 18,000 rpm, 300 Hz, ER20 and 7 kg. Both are documented at 288.5 mm overall. Matching these headline values does not identify which fixing arrangement will fit. Name the base or housing variant and compare its geometry with the bracket or machine structure.

GDF80-24Z/2.2B instead offers an 80 mm cylindrical-body example with ER20, 24,000 rpm and 400 Hz. Its clamp length is 125 mm. The family therefore contains different mounting questions even at equal rated output. Compare the motor's airflow and service access after the mechanical arrangement is identified; selecting an air-cooled series is not permission to enclose its cooling path.

GDF46-18Z/2.2 installation drawing
GDF46 base-mount drawing. Compare fixing geometry with the housing-mount variant before choosing the physical configuration.
Open original image

Zoom to read details. Scroll horizontally or vertically to move around the image.

GDF46-18Z/2.2 installation drawing

GDZ: choose the tool connection and cylindrical installation

GDZ is the manual water-cooled family in the current catalog. The three representative configurations show why power class does not replace a tooling or mounting description. GDZ-18-2 has 0.8 kW rated output, ER11B, a 65 mm body and 224 mm overall length. GDZ-17B has 1.5 kW, ER16, an 80 mm body and 241 mm overall length.

GDZ-23 adds a 2.2 kW, ER20 example with an 80 mm body, 120 mm clamp length and 268.5 mm overall length. All three are documented at 24,000 rpm and 400 Hz, but those shared operating values do not erase the interface and installation differences. Keep the distinct ER11B label with its supplied tooling requirements.

A machine with a suitable water circuit still needs the correct hoses, connection access and clamp region for the chosen unit. If the existing tool inventory is the governing requirement, investigate other configurations within the power class before changing the motor output. The 0.8/1.5/2.2 kW comparison explores that decision using specific GDZ examples.

GDK: compare each model's point, curve and tooling

GDK is also manual and water-cooled, but the examples here need careful reading of their documented ranges and curves. GDK100-12-24Z/2.2-4.4 is rated at 2.2 kW, uses ER20 and is documented over 12,000–24,000 rpm. Its original source gives separate power/torque curves and duty conditions. A suffix containing 4.4 does not establish unqualified continuous 4.4 kW output.

GDK110-9-18Z/2.2-4.4 uses ER25 and a 9,000–18,000 rpm range. Its body, clamp length and mass are 110 mm, 155 mm and 16 kg. Compare those requirements with GDK100's 100 mm body, 140 mm clamp and 12 kg. A change within GDK can affect both the tool inventory and the support structure.

GDK125-12-24Z/7.5 supplies a larger ER32, 7.5 kW rated example over 12,000–24,000 rpm. It is documented at 30 kg, with a 125 mm body and 190 mm clamp length. Neither a larger ER family nor higher output establishes that a given Z-axis can support the assembly. Read the power/torque guide and the actual drawing before finalizing its operating requirement.

Compare equal power without assuming equal installation

Four 2.2 kW examples make a useful cross-family exercise. GDF46 and GDZ-23 both use ER20 manual tooling but differ in speed, cooling and mounting. GDK100 adds a model-specific speed range, curve and larger mechanical assembly. GDL80 introduces ISO20 automatic exchange, auxiliary connections and an 800 Hz rated point.

Compare equal power without assuming equal installation
2.2 kW exampleMain difference from GDZ-23Required comparison
GDF46 base mountAir cooling, base fixing, 18,000 rpm / 300 HzMachine support and available airflow
GDK100Larger body/mass, speed range and separate curvesWorking point, duty and mount
GDL80 ISO20ATC holders and release system; 800 Hz rated pointRack, controls, pneumatics and drive
GDZ-23Reference ER20 manual water-cooled configurationExact bracket, winding and water services

This exercise gives the series names practical meaning. If the buyer needs to retain manual ER20 tooling and a cylindrical mount, an ATC example creates a different project. If air cooling is essential, the water-cooled examples create a service change. Mark those differences in the shortlist instead of comparing only price or nominal output.

Read the code with the supplied drawing and variant

Keep every model suffix, printed separator and configuration label in the order record. The same name can appear on distinct physical structures, and a code can include values that need their source conditions. Treat the code as an identifier linked to a drawing, not a universal formula for every dimension or performance limit.

A winding option is another part of the exact configuration. For GDL120, 220 V/19 A and 380 V/11 A are documented pairs. For GDK100, 269–380 V belongs to the operating curve across 400–800 Hz. These two forms of information serve different purposes. The VFD guide explains how to separate them.

Where the nameplate and drawing differ, retain both documents and obtain the supplied-unit specification. Do not silently choose a value from an adjacent model. A clear record of the variant, source and unresolved field helps the machine integrator review the candidate without reconstructing how a generic catalog description was interpreted.

Build a shortlist from the non-negotiable requirements

Write down the requirements that eliminate candidates: tool connection, change method, documented working point, allowed mass, mounting and services. Then select the family and compare its configurations. This order keeps the investigation efficient; a detailed electrical comparison is unnecessary for a motor already excluded by the required holder interface.

Consider a hypothetical manual machine retaining ER20 and an 80 mm bracket. GDF80-24Z/2.2B and GDZ-23 provide air- and water-cooled candidates with similar headline speed and output, but different clamp and cooling conditions. GDF46 requires a different mounting discussion, while GDL80 requires a holder and ATC-system discussion. None becomes interchangeable merely because its output is 2.2 kW.

Use the shortlist to communicate acceptable changes. If the machine builder is willing to redesign a bracket or add water cooling, record that as a separate proposal with its own acceptance. When existing services must remain, mark that constraint explicitly. This makes the supplier's alternatives relevant to the project instead of expanding the list with unrelated models.

Use drawings to compare the mechanical configurations

Put the exact candidate drawings next to the machine mounting sketch and use a common reference. Identify the surface or support region that locates each spindle, then compare nose position and rear clearance from that reference. This avoids treating a shorter overall motor as proof of better tool reach. The assembled holder and cutter must remain identified in the comparison.

For the two GDF46 examples, make the physical structure the first field. Their shared operating data does not eliminate the difference between a base fixing arrangement and housing fixing. Mark the required bracket or support design on the proposal. For a GDF80/GDZ23 comparison, keep cylindrical body diameter, permitted support region and cooling routes separate. An 80 mm label narrows the investigation but does not complete it.

For GDK100, GDK110 and GDK125, compare the actual mass, support dimensions and tooling inventory. The progression from ER20 to ER25 to ER32 is meaningful when the intended shanks require it, while the increasing assembly size is a separate machine-design consequence. Do not rank these configurations as universally better or worse without the working requirement and available axis structure.

For GDL70, retain the long-nose or short-nose identity with the original drawing. Their 551 mm and 471 mm overall lengths describe different assemblies, so compare the nose and mounting references against the machine separately. The available long-nose data does not state its mass; obtain the mass for the supplied assembly before completing the axis and support review rather than transferring the short-nose value.

The result is a mechanical comparison with explicit fit evidence and open requirements. It can be attached to the series shortlist so the supplier sees why a family was selected and what exact configuration the installer needs. When a mounting or service change is accepted, update the machine proposal rather than allowing the change to remain implied by a product name.

Record the family decision and the complete configuration

A useful order comparison contains the full code and physical structure, tool interface, output at the required speed, cooling, winding and mounting evidence. Include the machine and job requirement as context. Identify which series was rejected and why, so a later substitute can be evaluated against the same criteria.

Record the family decision and the complete configuration
Order fieldEvidence to retain
Configuration identityFull code, physical variant and supplied drawing
Tooling and exchangeIndividual collets or exact holders/retention parts
Operating requirementSpeed, documented output, duty and drive output
Mechanical installationMount reference, support region, mass and clearance
ServicesCooling, auxiliaries, and ATC air/sensing where applicable
AcceptanceDocument, fit, commissioning and representative job checks

Complete the order against the selected configuration's technical drawing and supplied operating data. Retain its full code, physical variant, tooling, winding and accepted installation requirements with the machine records. When maintenance or replacement is needed, compare the proposed assembly with that installed baseline, including any changes to support, services or operating conditions, rather than relying on the family name alone.

FAQ

Technical Questions and Configuration Limits

What is the main difference between the four HQD series?

The configurations compared here include GDL automatic-tool-change spindles, GDF manual air-cooled spindles, and GDZ/GDK manual water-cooled spindles. The exact tool interface, working point, mounting arrangement and services still need to be checked for each model.

Are GDZ and GDK spindles interchangeable because both are water-cooled?

Compare the exact tool interface, body and support region, mass, working point, drive and connections. A cooling category does not establish interchangeability.

Which GDF46-18Z/2.2 mounting version should I order?

Identify the existing or planned fixing arrangement and compare the base-mount and housing-mount drawings. Include the chosen physical variant in the inquiry.

Does the GDK 2.2-4.4 suffix mean 4.4 kW continuous output?

Read the exact source curves and their duty conditions. The GDK100 example has a cataloged 2.2 kW rated value and separate conditioned curves.

Does the series name identify the VFD settings?

No. Frequency, winding and current belong to the exact model and supplied configuration. Equal speed or power does not imply equal drive requirements.

What must be checked when comparing another configuration from the same series?

Compare its exact tool interface, rated point or operating curve, mounting arrangement, mass, winding and required services. Retain the original drawing and identify any unresolved information. Shared series names and nominal output do not establish mechanical interchangeability or an identical drive requirement.

NEXT STEP

Compare HQD Configurations for Your Machine

Send the required tool interface, tool-change method, working point, machine mount and available cooling/drive services. Include the shortlisted series and exact variants, quantity and destination.

Request a Spindle Check